diff --git a/fw/fw/thread.go b/fw/fw/thread.go
index a301f01c..e9eb835a 100644
--- a/fw/fw/thread.go
+++ b/fw/fw/thread.go
@@ -519,7 +519,7 @@ func (t *Thread) processIncomingData(packet *defn.Pkt) {
 			pitEntry.SetSatisfied(true)
 
 			// Insert into dead nonce list
-			for _, outRecord := range pitEntries[0].OutRecords() {
+			for _, outRecord := range pitEntry.OutRecords() {
 				t.deadNonceList.Insert(data.NameV, outRecord.LatestNonce)
 			}
 
diff --git a/fw/fw/thread_test.go b/fw/fw/thread_test.go
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..1055698b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/fw/fw/thread_test.go
@@ -0,0 +1,89 @@
+package fw
+
+import (
+	"testing"
+
+	"github.com/named-data/ndnd/fw/core"
+	"github.com/named-data/ndnd/fw/defn"
+	"github.com/named-data/ndnd/fw/dispatch"
+	"github.com/named-data/ndnd/fw/table"
+	enc "github.com/named-data/ndnd/std/encoding"
+	"github.com/named-data/ndnd/std/types/optional"
+	"github.com/stretchr/testify/assert"
+)
+
+type fakeFace struct {
+	id   uint64
+	sent []dispatch.OutPkt
+}
+
+func (f *fakeFace) String() string                 { return "fakeFace" }
+func (f *fakeFace) SetFaceID(faceID uint64)        { f.id = faceID }
+func (f *fakeFace) FaceID() uint64                 { return f.id }
+func (f *fakeFace) LocalURI() *defn.URI            { return nil }
+func (f *fakeFace) RemoteURI() *defn.URI           { return nil }
+func (f *fakeFace) Scope() defn.Scope              { return defn.NonLocal }
+func (f *fakeFace) LinkType() defn.LinkType        { return defn.PointToPoint }
+func (f *fakeFace) MTU() int                       { return 9000 }
+func (f *fakeFace) State() defn.State              { return defn.Up }
+func (f *fakeFace) SendPacket(out dispatch.OutPkt) { f.sent = append(f.sent, out) }
+
+func mkInterest(nameStr string, canBePrefix bool, nonce uint32) *defn.FwInterest {
+	name, err := enc.NameFromStr(nameStr)
+	if err != nil {
+		panic(err)
+	}
+	return &defn.FwInterest{
+		NameV:        name,
+		CanBePrefixV: canBePrefix,
+		NonceV:       optional.Some(nonce),
+	}
+}
+
+func TestDataMultiPitMatchDeadNonceList(t *testing.T) {
+	core.C.Tables.ContentStore.ReplacementPolicy = "lru"
+	core.C.Tables.Fib.Algorithm = "nametree"
+	table.Initialize()
+	table.CfgSetCsAdmit(false)
+	table.CfgSetCsServe(false)
+
+	thread := NewThread(0)
+
+	downstream := &fakeFace{id: 100}
+	upstream := &fakeFace{id: 200}
+	dispatch.AddFace(100, downstream)
+	dispatch.AddFace(200, upstream)
+	defer dispatch.RemoveFace(100)
+	defer dispatch.RemoveFace(200)
+
+	// Two pending interests that both match Data /a/b:
+	//  /a   (CanBePrefix=true),  nonce 1111
+	//  /a/b (CanBePrefix=false), nonce 2222
+	// Both were forwarded upstream (face 200) with their respective nonces.
+	interestA := mkInterest("/a", true, 1111)
+	pitEntryA, _ := thread.pitCS.InsertInterest(interestA, nil, downstream.id)
+	pitEntryA.InsertInRecord(interestA, downstream.id, nil)
+	pitEntryA.InsertOutRecord(interestA, upstream.id)
+
+	interestB := mkInterest("/a/b", false, 2222)
+	pitEntryB, _ := thread.pitCS.InsertInterest(interestB, nil, downstream.id)
+	pitEntryB.InsertInRecord(interestB, downstream.id, nil)
+	pitEntryB.InsertOutRecord(interestB, upstream.id)
+
+	// Data /a/b arrives from upstream.
+	dataName, _ := enc.NameFromStr("/a/b")
+	packet := &defn.Pkt{
+		Name:           dataName,
+		L3:             &defn.FwPacket{Data: &defn.FwData{NameV: dataName}},
+		IncomingFaceID: upstream.id,
+	}
+	thread.processIncomingData(packet)
+
+	// Both entries got satisfied and data went downstream.
+	assert.Equal(t, 2, len(downstream.sent))
+
+	// The out-nonces of BOTH satisfied PIT entries must be in the dead nonce
+	// list, so a looped interest carrying either nonce is dropped.
+	assert.True(t, thread.deadNonceList.Find(dataName, 2222), "nonce of /a/b entry missing from DNL")
+	assert.True(t, thread.deadNonceList.Find(dataName, 1111), "nonce of /a entry missing from DNL")
+}